Attention: You are now leaving a Wintrust Community Bank website.

Bill O'Toole


Downtown Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Meet Our Board

Downtown Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Meet Our Board

Bill O’Toole is the president and CEO of Catholic Financial Life in Milwaukee. He serves on several boards including the American Fraternal Alliance, the United Community Center of Milwaukee, and the Wisconsin Better Business Bureau. 

Bill earned the Board Leadership Fellow designation from the National Association of Corporate Directors. In 2013, he received the Distinguished Alumnus of the Year award from the Marquette University Intercollegiate Athletics Department. He’s also been recognized with the Friend of the Hispanic Community award by the UCC and the Board of the Year award in 2017 from Foley’s National Directors Institute. 

A native of St. Louis, Bill received his bachelor’s degree from Marquette University and his MBA from Cardinal Stritch University. Bill and his wife, Karolyn, live in Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin.